M.E. in the media: the aftershocks continue

All the news that's unfit to print?

Earthquakes always have aftershocks, don't they? Just read this in 'The Times Higher Educational Supplement' online.

Just when we were starting to think that maybe, just maybe, certain muck-spreaders and mischief-mongers (oh no, could that be counted as a death threat?) had done their worst, the Times Higher Ed decides to recycle the recent press feeding frenzy and now to concertina all the accusations into one punchy paragraph.

I haven't the strength left to be surprised or disappointed (does that make me mentally unbalanced, I wonder?) It's the same old, same old, compressed into a handy pill-sized gobbet of "news" summary that makes it look like irrefutable fact.

Surely these unnamed hordes of M.E. suffering extremists must have a hell of a lot more energy than you or I to terrorise the poor ickle psychs like this?

I quote, peeping through my fingers:

• Scientists researching chronic fatigue syndrome - also known as myalgic encephalomyelitis, or ME - are being targeted by activists who are now as dangerous as animal rights extremists, it has been claimed. The militants, who object to any suggestion that the illness has psychological causes, have turned up at lectures with knives, punched scientists in the street and issued death threats, it was reported on 21 August. They are also said to have bombarded researchers with Freedom of Information requests, made countless complaints to university ethics committees, and falsely alleged that scientists pursuing work in the subject are in the pay of drug and insurance companies. Myra McClure, head of infectious diseases at Imperial College London, told The Observer: "I published a study which these extremists did not like and was subjected to a staggering volley of horrible abuse. One man wrote he was having pleasure imagining that he was watching me drown. He sent that every day for months."

www.timeshighereducation.co.uk


Sadly, this is neither higher, nor educational.

Hopefully not to the psychiatric school beginning with "W"!

N.B. There was also a cartoon to go with the Times Higher Ed article, but this was later withdrawn. Hopefully they will not later claim this was because they received death threats!
If your health and blood pressure are up to it, the said cartoon can be seen here. Thanks to Dr Speedy at Niceguidelines blogspot for preserving a link to it for the sake of truth!



Many thanks for the 'heads up' about the THES article from @Velogubbed on Twitter. Her own wonderful M.E. and writing related blog can be enjoyed here:


http://velo-gubbed-legs.blogspot.com/

If you haven't read her fantastic book about her life with M.E. yet, please do yourself a favour and put that right: 'The State of Me' by Nasim Marie Jafry is available on Amazon and good bookshops.

M.E. in the media: why let the truth get in the way of a good story?

Myalgic Encephalomyelitis is not a mental disorder.

Let me start with the simple fact. Medical research has shown it. The World Health Organisation has recognised it. Everyone with M.E. knows it to their cost. How much simpler it would be if we could walk away from M.E. after a cosy chat about our "illness beliefs" and a few phased-in press-ups!

No right-thinking M.E. sufferer wants anything but a cure and their former health back. For children and young people who never knew a healthy life before M.E. struck, just the cure and a happy normal future would do.


We do not want psychiatrists harmed or threatened. Of course not! What are people thinking? Like me, none but a handful of (as yet curiously unnamed) desperately sick individuals at the end of their tether, would wish harm on anybody. Let alone issue death threats. This is appalling to us all.

But smokescreen coverage of the "victimisation" of those seeking to turn back the clock to the days when the mistaken insult "Yuppie Flu" reigned in the minds of a largely uninformed public, has pothered up around the illness that has stolen our lives and livelihoods for so long on a daily basis. While this mass media story goes viral, it is in danger of snuffing out bona fide campaigning for scientific medical progress into M.E. treatment and cure. That would be the real tragedy.

M.E. is not a mental disorder.

It bears no resemblance to bi-polar depression, Munchhausen's By Proxy, schizophrenia or any other mental illness. Any more than M.S. was ever really "hysterical paralysis" or Tuberculosis was ever cured by shoving dying men and women out into the sun to do them good in spite of their wrong "illness beliefs"!


M.E. is NOT a mental disorder.


There seems no end of confusion about this fact. Not helped by the recent onslaught of misinformation, half-truths and lies in the media.

Let me repeat in case anybody is still in doubt:

 M.E. is not a mental disorder.

I understand the confusion. There's a whole Tower of Babel being erected in the press with a confusion of voices shouting from their own corners out of vested interest.

Scientific research is costly. More costly than the cheap talking therapies and often hugely damaging regimes of exercise forced on muscles and mitochondria that are made all the more sick by such tactics. Those M.E. patients like myself who have always driven ourselves to our limits however we felt, have already discovered to our cost the dire consequences of such determination to show our bodies "tough love"!


Scientific biomedical research into M.E. is expensive. But it's not a luxury. It is vital.

So far it has shown the truth that M.E. is a physical illness, not some vague conglomeration of imaginary symptoms making sufferers turn from hard-working, articulate, driven, fully-functioning pillars of society into benefit-bludging, lazy hypochondriacs. Who on earth do you think you are labelling? Are your memories so pathetically short? Where were you knockers, disbelievers and haters when we were saving your lives in the operating theatre or baptising your babies, successfully fighting your lawsuits or striding along optimistically helping to change the world where we all paid tax while we could? That was us M.E. sufferers, just like you! We were (and would love to be again!) your co-workers, crisis solvers and your children!

Recent articles in papers like the Sunday Times and Observer, may have misled you. They probably intended to. By doing so they enable the government, DWP and paid psychiatrists to feel justified in forcing some of the sickest and most vulnerable people in our society, with an illness every bit as disabling as M.S. or polio, into work they are too fluctuatingly, severely ill to fulfil without relapse, or into cheap and ineffective forms of treatment, which is actually designed to manage mental health problems, or psychosomatic syndromes yet often causes M.E. patients to crash and burn.

These treatments include the cheap-to-fund non-invasive and unscientific cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) or graded exercise therapy (GET) aimed at weaning patients off damaging sickness-perpetuating habits and thought patterns. This does not work with physiological, multi-systemic diseases like M.E., M.S., Cancer, Tuberculosis, Polio, Myasthenia Gravis or Diabetes Mellitus. So why is this the only funded "treatment" available for M.E.? Why? How can our mental aberrations make us too dangerous to donate blood?



Contrary to what has been stated in the media, please listen to the words and understand:

Neurological DOES NOT mean neurotic. 


 Physical disease DOES NOT mean psychological disease.

Physiological illness DOES NOT mean psychosomatic illness.


It really is that simple.

M.E. has been classified by the World Health Organisation and M.E. researchers who are not tied to proving a money-saving, non-scientific theory to keep truthful enquiry at bay as follows:

a serious multi-system neuroimmune disorder affecting the central, autonomic and peripheral nervous systems as well as the immune, cardiovascular, respiratory, neuroendocrine, gastrointestinal, musculo-skeletal, visual and reproductive systems. 


Is that clear enough?

Yet again the papers have rushed into a feeding frenzy on the say-so of certain individuals, borrowing each others' tag lines and taking the easy route to a sensational story.

Why let the truth get in the way of a good story?


Why?

Unfortunately it's too late to ask those who have already died of the effects of M.E. like Sophie Mirza, Lynn Gilderdale and others who make up the 3% of M.E. patients for whom it proves fatal with deaths due to tumours, cardiac failure, brain death and liver failure, sudden collapse after overexertion or exercise and the effects of a slowly worsening illness or, horrifyingly in the 21st century, inappropriate medical "care". Around 30% of M.E. cases are progressive and degenerative. More info on these stats: The Hummingbirds' Foundation for M.E.


Why let the truth get in the way of a good story? I think we all know by now why it must not be allowed to.

Let's go on raising awareness of M.E. in whatever peaceful, respectful but dog-with-a-bone determined ways we can, if we can, whenever and however we can.

If you're still in doubt how medical science is still being ignored at the highest level of UK decision-making in favour of the dangerously contrary all-in-the-mind model of M.E., you can read this post in the excellent blog Dancing with the Sandman:


Letters from Malcolm Hooper Emeritus Professor of Medicinal Chemistry University of Sunderland, to Iain Duncan Smith MP DWP and Andrew Lansley MP Sec of State for Health

The Truth Is Out There!

The Truth Is Out There. The Truth About M.E./CFS/CFIDS.

But some powerful bum steers have hit the tarmac with a bigger bang, since last I wrote.


Did anybody else notice how soon after the news of Dr Myhill's exoneration of all misconduct charges by the General Medical Council, the pernicious nonsense peddled by Prof Simon Wessely hit the papers? Of course you did!


BBC News covers "victim" Wessely


Daily Mail covers "victim" Wessely


The Economist (where will this end???) covers "victim" Wessely


Top News US covers "victim" Wessely


Visit Bulgaria covers "victim" Wessely

Top News New Zealand covers "victim" Wessely 

Followed up by the slack journalism in the Times by Stephanie Marsh on Aug 6th 
Doctor's hate mail is sent by the people he tried to cure 

and the hackery of Rod Liddle on 31st July with his dismissively mocking
Shoot the medical messenger - see if that'll cure you

So that's pretty much worldwide coverage, then. Raising awareness of M.E.? Sadly, for all the wrong, mistaken reasons. How now to explain all this to friends, neighbours and strangers who have taken this new story on board over their cornflakes, I can't begin to know. 

Happily, most of them already know how little this is a state of mind, and those who knew me before I was ill, understand how the physical illness I fought for years finally took its worst toll, thriving on my opposition to lying down under its tyranny!

A few calculated words from a man who knows full well that time will prove him wrong, and has all the painful fight for M.E. research been swept away in a tide of headline-grabbing rhetoric and half-truths?

A drop of misinformation in already muddied waters. The ripples from this one have gone far indeed!

Amazing how, suddenly, all the decades of research on the physical causes and deeper understanding of this crushingly painful, debilitating neurological multi-systemic disease  (that definition's NOT coming from M.E. patients, but from scientists, researchers, doctors and the World Health Organisation who must also be insulted and mystified that Simon Wessely is now a self-proclaimed "leading expert in M.E.' ???) which rarely gets a mention in the media, has been outstripped by an outmoded and, franky, wholly incorrect analysis of the disease!



You know by now, I'm an optimist. My optimism hasn't been so sorely tried in the years since M.E. (not that woolly umbrella that lets the poison rain in, called "CFS") was diagnosed in my case. I was full of life, optimism, joy, hard work, fun, plans. I still am, ready for when M.E. ceases to pull the carpet unexpectedly from under me.

These articles have made me determined, after a period of sober reflection, that there is all the more need for those of us who can, to keep positive and do all we can to go on holding out for the day when the truth is known and the correct treatments and cures will finally come our way. Sadly for those like Sophie Mirza and Lynn Gilderdale, it will come too late.


The Truth is Out There. 

Not just on the X Files, either.

Professor Wessely knows it, and maybe that's why he has used what influence he has with the media and government to rekindle old ideas and theories about M.E. (experts have called it that, incidentally, not those of us who didn't know any name for the disease that snatched our lives and livelihoods away) that distract the eyes of the world from what is right under its nose, with horrifying sensationalism and sleight of hand.


The Truth is Out There.

We have to keep on believing that, and not letting playground bullies kick us when we are furthest down! Sticks and stones may hurt our bones (if not as much as M.E.!) but calling will not hurt us (when we've stopped weeping in disbelief at the lies levelled at derailing real scientific enquiry!)


Much has already been written to point out the glaring errors in these articles. I've been so thankful for them. We all have:


Actual BBC caller suffering from M.E. speaks the truth

Niceguidelines.blogspot.com - one of so many excellent posts 

Letter on MEA Website 


Letters responding to Rod Liddle's article in The Sunday Times


I have pushed myself to the maximun over the last few weeks. Doing a tiny part of what used to be my full-time vocation, now vountarily and with consequences that make me immobile and inarticuate now for ages afterwards. Receiving those visitors who can only get away to see me in the summer. Luckily they understand my limitations!


All in my head? I think we all know it isn't, whatever we read in the papers. Or hear from little green men.